Dashboard/Andy Burnham

Andy Burnham

Prime Minister of the UK · Labour Party
22 BS INDEX 0 100
Mostly straight talk
Bluff17%Spin28%

Our model rated these statements. Lower is better.

Answers questions
72%

73 questions rated. Answered = 1, Partly answered and Declined openly = ½, Dodged = 0.

Answered 37Partly answered 22Declined openly 9Dodged 5
Prime Minister, I'm going to get on to your incredibly consequential speech in a moment, but before I do, you've said there is a strong indication that Iran was involved in the Fairfield plot. That is very serious indeed. Yes. Will you recall Parliament?
Partly answeredAsked whether he will recall Parliament. Confirms the belief that Iran played a part but does not address recall, which is asked again next.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
AnsweredSays there is no urgent need now but he would recall Parliament if necessary.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Okay. And right, okay, Prime Minister, thank you for that. Now, you said in your speech yesterday that you want to draw a line on a decade of division. Yeah. And then you announced a series of very divisive policies, changing the triple lock, potentially tearing up Britain's voting system, or pursuing reationalization, potentially reopening Brexit wars. Your politics are full of dividing lines, aren't they?
AnsweredRejects the description and says the choices have majority support and he did not attack other parties.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Yes, indeed. And Prime Minister, I'm going to I want to come on to a couple of those policies, but just in terms of your reform agenda for Britain, voting uh reform, the EU, social care, it all requires a general election, will you call one before 2029?
DodgedAsked whether he will call a general election before 2029. Replies that electoral reform is not divisive.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But your big reform, but your big reform program requires a general election, doesn't it?
AnsweredSays not everything needs an election and that the triple lock change lets care preparations start now.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
So you you're not going to call a general election till 2029.
AnsweredSays plainly he will not call an early general election.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
PM, even what you want to do, give people some breathing space. You can't deliver on that, can you? One think tank is estimating every household will be nearly 2.5,000 worse off by the end of next year. That's just the reality, isn't it? You can't deliver that.
Partly answeredAsked whether he can deliver breathing space given forecasts of households £2,500 worse off. Says 'I can do what I can'.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But you can people are going to be worse off, aren't they? Before they get better.
Partly answeredAsked whether people will be worse off. Lists the VAT cut and bus fare cap and says some pressures are beyond his control, without a yes or no.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Just to be just so but just to be for people out there cuz you've talked a lot about breathing space. Can you just be honest with them? It's going to get worse for them before it gets better, isn't it? I'm not saying it's your fault. A lot of it is beyond your control. It's going to beough. It's going to get worse.
AnsweredSays it is going to be a tough winter.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
What are you saying to people issues around bed in there and I will do what I can when I can. Is that what you're saying?
AnsweredSays he will help where he can but will not propose unfunded measures.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But it is going to get worse before it gets better. Just Yes. Isn't it?
Partly answeredAsked again whether it will get worse. Accepts it for energy prices, then turns to better-than-expected growth figures.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
PM I'm already running out of time, so I'm going to have to crack on. Um just on the policies, you've said you want to start a debate on Britain's long-term relationship with our European partners. one option you said is going all the way. Might the next election be a referendum on rejoining the EU?
Declined openlyAsked whether the next election could be a referendum on rejoining. Says it is 'way too early to jump to that conclusion'.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
AnsweredSays he believes Britain needs to get closer to Europe.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You've said in the past that you think that we will rejoin the EU in your lifetime, you're still a relatively young man. Do you would would you in your heart like to go back into I'm saying personally.
Partly answeredAsked whether he personally wants to rejoin. Refers to his earlier 'in my lifetime' remark without saying yes or no.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
I'm not saying it becomes policy. I just want people to understand what you believe
Partly answeredAsked to say what he personally believes. Calls it a 'principle feeling' that depends on the terms.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Well if there was an option to join tomorrow on past terms would you take it?
DodgedAsked whether he would rejoin tomorrow on past terms. Lists other options instead.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You just said you don't want now according to polls has a majority said you don't want to return.
AnsweredSays public opinion has changed and the aim is to set out options and look for consensus.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
PM, I'm really running out of time, but just quickly uh your change to the triple lock will save the government 15 billion pounds by 2040. It still won't be enough to pay for social care. You will have to raise taxes as well, won't you?
Partly answeredAsked whether he will also have to raise taxes. Says the savings would be enough but not immediately, then talks about fairness for pensioners.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
AnsweredSays no, a phased introduction avoids tax rises, and mentions Baroness Casey's review.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
and you've spoken so powerfully about it and I do want to come if I may to your dad Roy. There was a moment on stage yesterday and I was right at the front and I I saw you so closely when his name came up on the teleprompter and you just stopped. Mhm. And then the hall began to cheer you on. What was going through your mind at that time? Did you think you couldn't carry on?
AnsweredDescribes what he was feeling and why he spoke about his father and the union.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Well, that was one thing I did want to ask cuz you were back out on duty just a couple of days after your dad died, which was quite incredible that you managed to get yourself up and out again. Um, and you said then that your dad would have wanted you to be back out there and you said bringing some of the changes he always pushed you to make. Social care is clearly one of those changes. What else do you think your dad would want you to do as prime minister?
AnsweredLists what his father would want: boldness on social care, growth, technical education.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You said that people can't wait forever for change in your speech on this stage. So, why in that speech did you set out a whole series of major changes an actual care service, a closer relationship with Europe, changing our voting system, none of which can happen for years?
AnsweredAsked why the speech set out long-term changes after saying people can't wait. Points to short-term measures (VAT, bus fares) and says the bigger fixes take time.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Let's go through some of the changes starting with that big one on social care. Why hit pensioners not the wealthiest in your first big policy announcement?
Partly answeredAsked why the policy takes from pensioners rather than the wealthiest. Says it helps pensioners facing care costs; does not address why the wealthiest are not asked to pay.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
I'm asking you how you pay for that because you you've set out that ambition repeatedly. What's new is you've now told us how you want to pay for it. And you're wanting to pay for it by scrapping the triple lock, by scrapping the guarantee to pensioners.
AnsweredAsked how social care will be paid for, by scrapping the triple lock. Rejects 'scrapping' and says it is an adjustment, which he goes on to explain.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But let's put it simply, the clever people behind the scenes who brief us after speeches like your speech say, "This will save 15 billion pounds a year eventually." That's 15 billion pounds that would have been going to pensioners, which is why I ask you, "Why are you taking money from pensioners and not," as Sharon Graham of Unite the Union would say, "take it from the wealthy. Don't take it from pensioners."
Partly answeredAsked why take money from pensioners and not the wealthy. Says pensioners will gain peace of mind over care costs; does not address taxing the wealthy.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You You're saying it's a deal, forgive me interrupting, but you're saying effectively it's a deal. You get something new, but we have to take something back a bit.
Partly answeredAsked whether it is effectively a trade-off for pensioners. Calls it a first big move towards a national care service without confirming or rejecting the trade-off.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
check what you mean by that, you see, because you've talked about a free national care service, free at the point of use. But can we be clear that is if you get care in your own home? If you go into a residential home like your dad did, for example, you'll still pay your bed and board, won't you?
AnsweredConfirms people in residential homes will still pay bed and board.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
might end up selling your family house to pay the bills which are what, 50 to 100,000 pounds?
AnsweredSays costs could be even more and bed and board will still be paid, then explains why better home care matters.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
very clear. You've been honest about it, as you said you would be, which is people who move into a residential home, they still face the risk of losing their home to pay those bills. Can we deal with the crisis that's facing people now, this winter? The boss of EDF, the big energy firm, has been talking to the BBC, and he says this winter we face another energy crisis. Is that how you see it as Prime Minister?
AnsweredSays yes, this is an energy crisis, linked to the war with Iran.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
And you're going to have to look at giving people more help, because you proclaim from this stage that you were cutting VAT off electricity bills, as you've just said. Now, you'll know the numbers. That saves people around £45 off their energy bill. But, prices are going up by £60 a year tomorrow. They're due to go up, that's the forecast, another £276. So, your VAT cut's already been wiped out. Will you look at further help?
AnsweredAgrees the VAT cut will not meet all the pressures and says further measures are being considered for the budget.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly answeredAsked about fuel duty. Says any measure is being looked at, without addressing fuel duty itself.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Now, if there's an energy crisis, as you've conceded, there's another crisis at the moment globally, a borrowing crisis. The global markets are demanding more to lend countries money than they have for, what, 20 years or so. But Britain has a particular problem. It costs more for the Treasury here to borrow money than it costs Greece, than it costs Italy, than it costs France. Why didn't you say something in this big speech today to try and say to the global markets, "We've got this under control. We're going to cut spending. We aren't going to borrow as much in the future."
AnsweredAsked why the speech did not reassure markets. Says he did, through the triple lock decision, and attributes the higher borrowing costs to the mini budget.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
doesn't that doesn't make our borrowing any better.
Partly answeredTold that spending the savings does not help borrowing. Argues public control will cut long-term costs; does not address near-term borrowing.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Well, you hope it'll reduce revenue spending, but the point I'm making to you is that you then plan to spend it on something else. So, not just social care, but the other thing you didn't spend long talking about. You are committed to a huge increase in defense spending and you've yet to tell us how you'll pay for it. And we still don't know the answer and there's no prospect of an answer if as soon as you make a cut to spending you say, "Oh, I've got a plan to expand government. We'll get a national care service. Let's spend it on that."
Partly answeredAsked how defence spending will be paid for. Says it will be fully funded and set out at the budget, without saying how.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
I want to ask you briefly if I could about two other big changes that you talked about from this conference stage. Brexit. Ideally, in your heart, you want us to rejoin the EU, don't you?
Partly answeredAsked whether he wants to rejoin the EU. Says he wants to look at the options, without a yes or no.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Mr. Burnham. That sounds like yes, but I don't want to say it.
AnsweredSays he has written that he would like Britain to rejoin in his lifetime, but not necessarily now, and lists the options.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
There's another big reform you spoke about, Prime Minister, which is voting reform. You're saying that's what you want to happen, that we have European style voting in Britain.
AnsweredExplains why he favours voting reform, citing his mayoral elections and five-party politics.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
words, you want to stop Nigel Farage becoming Prime Minister.
AnsweredSays no, it could apply to any party, and argues for stability.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Again and again, when you wanted to be Prime Minister, now you are Prime Minister, you talked about rolling back 40 years of of failure as you see it. Why, as Prime Minister now, do you talk more about the 1980s than about 2020s? Isn't it a backward-looking speech, rather than a speech that says, "Here are the big challenges, the energy crisis, the AI crisis, the crisis of what Russia is doing and what China is doing?"
AnsweredSays today's crises in energy, water and housing have their roots in the 1980s.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You talked very movingly about your father, who died just a couple of weeks ago. Wouldn't he have been the first to tell you, "Don't be nostalgic, son. Look [snorts] to the future. Look to your kids' future. Don't bang on about Margaret Thatcher."
AnsweredSays his father would not have said that and describes what his father taught him.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Forgive me. You You You saw a message that someone had predicted. John Swinney, is it? The First Minister of
AnsweredConfirms the remark he quoted, says he was not blaming its author, and explains why it stayed with him.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
You stood on this stage. There's the euphoria that you had. And when you came to the moment you were going to speak about your dad, you had to stop, didn't you? And people got to their feet to give you space to compose yourself. Does it just feel like you're on a an emotional roller coaster all the time?
AnsweredSays it has at times, and describes how he is using it for purpose in the job.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Prime Minister, welcome in your childhood stomping ground of Liverpool. Um in July, as we heard just there, you told us you would go as fast as you can on sorting out care for the elderly and vulnerable in England, social care as it's known. Where have you got to now, 3 months later?
Partly answeredAsked where he has got to on social care three months on. Says good progress is being made and he will grasp the nettle, without saying what has been done.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
If people weren't aware, your father, Roy, passed away actually less than 2 weeks ago. I think it's a fortnight tomorrow. So, this is obviously hugely personal for you, as it is personal for so many families who'll be watching this morning. What will a new system mean? What will you offer people? By when will it happen? So, let's start with what you're actually going to do.
Partly answeredAsked what a new system would offer and by when. Describes a national care service that works with the NHS and the problems with the current system; gives no timing.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
And those are the problems right now as you see it, but what are you to be really clear, are you proposing a universal service, universal free care for people? Let's be really specific here. Do you mean free personal care for everyone who needs it in England?
Partly answeredAsked whether he means universal free personal care. Says a system on NHS principles and more detail at the conference, without a yes or no.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
AnsweredAsked whether that means free at the point of use and universal. Says that is the only way to make it work and points to free personal care elsewhere in the UK.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
One of the reasons though why politicians have looked at this and then backed off is the cost. So, you've set out very clearly here you want there to be a system for everyone in England that is free at the point of use cuz you've committed to the same principles as the NHS. If you look at that what that might cost, some estimates say 18 billion pounds a year, that's Health Foundation figures. Some people estimate even more than that.
AnsweredTold one estimate puts the cost at 18 billion pounds a year. Says the figure is too high on the figures he has seen.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
DodgedAsked what the cost would be, then. Gives no figure and turns to the costs families and the NHS already bear.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
So, where will it do it from? Because where will it come from?
Declined openlyAsked where the money will come from. Says he will say more later in the week and a review is under way.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
So, let's then be You say you want to be honest, you want to look people in the eye. You can look the country in the eye right now and say you want care in England to be like the NHS. Everyone pays for the NHS. It comes out of general taxation. So, is that how this is going to work? Everyone will contribute if everyone's covered? Because that means more tax.
Partly answeredAsked whether everyone will contribute through tax. Says everyone contributes and is covered, but not necessarily as the NHS is funded, and leaves the method to the Casey review.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Prime Minister, you know where you're going with this. You've been thinking about this for years.
Declined openlyPressed that he knows where he is going with this. Says he will set it out in Tuesday's speech and explains why he will not do so in an interview.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
spread the cost across the population. That then sounds different to what you just mentioned, what you as Health Secretary mentioned all the way back at suggested back in 2009. Your proposal then, was to bring in a better system of social care paid for by among other ways, paid for by a levy on people's estates, the money they wanted to leave behind for their children. As you said, it was branded a dementia tax. Is that off the table?
AnsweredAsked whether an estate levy is off the table. Says nothing is off the table, but he is not necessarily returning to his 2010 proposal.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
If it's urgent, do you commit to doing this before 2029, before the next general election?
AnsweredAsked whether he commits to doing it before the 2029 election. Says manifesto commitments make that hard in this parliament.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
just to be clear for people that commitments in the manifesto are not raising VAT, not raising income tax, and not raising national insurance that employees pay. But there could be a different kind of tax. There could be a hypothecated tax to use the the fancy word. Just to stick on timing cuz that's the question I'm asking here, really.
AnsweredPressed on timing. Says he will put a plan to the public at the next general election and introduce it in the next parliament.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
So, to be really clear, you've just set this out there. You are going to put to the country at the next general election a proposition for a care service that will be free at the point of use, paid for by everyone, and that will be on the ballot paper next time round.
AnsweredAsked to confirm the proposal will be on the ballot paper. Confirms, with an explanation of how it will be funded.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But some people watching and your political critics and also a growing number of economists would say that the country is in the position it is because politicians have been too free with public money. They've not taken the economy seriously enough. They've not taken growing the economy seriously enough. And I just would would Let me Let me Let Let me ask this question because since you've been in power, you have outlined and talked about social care, but you've put more money more spending on housing. You want more money for rough sleeping, more money on cheaper bus fares. You've taken some money off energy bills. The problem comes on the other side of the ledger. Now, you've saved some money by canceling the digital ID project. That was 1 and 1/2 billion pounds, but money that actually hadn't been allocated in in the first place. What is it are you willing to ditch in order to make the sums add up? Because one of your critics, you know, said that you're like Father Christmas. You can't just be Santa Burnham. The economy is in quite a precarious state. The debt is 98% of the whole economy.
Partly answeredAsked what he would cut to make the sums add up. Argues his spending on care, rough sleeping and bus fares saves money later; names nothing he would cut.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
And there is concern in your party, too, that you're quite motivated and happy maybe to spend taxpayers' cash on things that you understandably care about, things that your party cares about. But the former business secretary Peter Kyle told us this weekend, you have to care as much about growing the economy as you do about rough sleeping or trying to give people a little bit of help.
AnsweredTold a former minister says he must care as much about growth. Agrees and cites growth in Greater Manchester and Liverpool.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
now and you know very well that there are many economists who look at the state of the UK and think this cannot go on in this way. So, where are you prepared to cut back
DodgedAsked where he is prepared to cut back. Rejects a 'narrative of doom' and cites G7 growth and the mini-budget, without naming any cut.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
No, no one is No one's asking for a gold medal. Oil is once again at 100 pounds a barrel. There are predictions that energy bills will hit five 500 pounds extra from January onwards. Yes, as Keir Starmer sat in that chair and did the same thing saying that yes, there were some good signs of growth. The point is there is real concern in the financial markets about the health of the British economy.
AnsweredTold there is real concern in financial markets. Agrees there is.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
So, can you tell us today somewhere where you're willing to cut or something that you're willing to ditch in order to balance the books?
Declined openlyAsked to name something he would cut. Says people should wait for Tuesday's speech, then discusses the Middle East conflict and prudence.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
One of the things though that people particularly in the business community but probably lots of people watching will look at and say is just, you know, might want to throw their hands up in exasperation. Again, building another runway at Heathrow seems to have been delayed. Rachel Reeves used to say that would bring billions of extra pounds to the economy. Are you going to back another runway Heathrow? There has to be a vote in Parliament.
Declined openlyAsked whether he backs a third Heathrow runway. Points to the consultation without giving a view.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Declined openlyAsked again whether he backs it. Calls it a contested issue mainly for London.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
a vote in Parliament and you're the Prime Minister. Are you going to back it or not?
Declined openlyAsked again, as Prime Minister with a vote due. Says it is not right to jump in before the consultation is considered.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
That sounds like you're not up for it cuz the London Mayor said he can't isn't that up for it.
Declined openlyTold he sounds unenthusiastic. Says there are different views to weigh before a decision.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Will the welfare bill have gone down by the next general election?
Partly answeredAsked whether the welfare bill will be lower by the election. Says he would like that to happen.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Declined openlyAsked to commit to it. Says he would if he could and explains he will not make crude cuts.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly answeredAsked whether the masked protesters are patriots. Calls them unacceptable and creating fear, then turns to migration figures, without addressing the word.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
Well, your home your home secretary said he was. She said he was an outright racist.
Partly answeredTold the Home Secretary called the protest leader an outright racist. Declines to apply the label as he has not read everything he has said, but calls his behaviour hateful.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
There are though, as you've said, people who are very worried about what's happening in their own communities. What do you say to the women of Paddington or villagers in Linton-on-Ouse in North Yorkshire who are really worried about these small communities being asked to live side by side with more than a thousand young men, asylum seekers, coming to live in their communities?
AnsweredAsked what he would say to communities near large asylum sites. Says their concerns are understandable and must be addressed, and explains the move away from hotels.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
pay the price for successive governments' failures? I mean, isn't there another solution? Your predecessor actually at one point was looking at trying to send people who'd come here without permission to other countries, to Albania. Now, that didn't work out. But are you prepared to look at something more radical?
DodgedAsked whether he would look at something more radical, such as removals to other countries. Says current tactics are working, without saying whether he would consider other options.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
But overall, the figure for this year is still higher than it was in 2024. So, yes, you're right, the number of summer crossings is lower than it has been for some time, but the overall figure this year is still happening. A couple of undocumented boats slipped through this week.
AnsweredTold the year's figure is still above 2024. Says crossings are down on last year and the early 2020s and more will be done.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
People might be able to hear this in protest going on outside. We're not sure what people are protesting about. It's quite a normal thing to happen at a party conference, but just if you can hear that in the background, then that is what is going on. I just lastly want to ask you about what's happening in Northern Ireland this morning. There's been real tension this morning between two communities, um the Drumcree, which of course years ago was the scene of some of the most serious disorder in Northern Ireland. Um the government could have overturned the decision here and said that the parade shouldn't be allowed to go ahead. What is your view of what's going on? Are you concerned about it?
AnsweredAsked his view of the Drumcree situation and whether the government could have stopped the parade. Disputes the premise, explains the process and appeals for calm. (Premise challenged.)Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person
A huge amount on your plate, and we're grateful for your time this morning. I just must ask you this. This is a huge week for you, huge moment. Someone in government said, "He just loves being Prime Minister." Is that true? You're loving it?
AnsweredAsked whether he loves being Prime Minister. Says yes, because of what he can do with the job.Our model rated this Not yet reviewed by a person

10 further exchange(s) not rated: procedural or ceremonial questions (a tribute, thanks or condolence that asks for nothing), or questions the speaker did not take.