No questions were put, so answering cannot be measured. Claims that held up: 71% of 14 checked (Bluff 14.3 of 50). Its claims still count towards the overall score.
Same event
9 Sep 2026
Everyone in our line-up who spoke here, each rated by the same rules on their own words. Our model rated this. The BS Index is not compared here because the speakers were scored on different measures (for example, one asked the questions and the other answered them). Compare the measures instead.
Kemi Badenochthis transcript
Leader of the Opposition
71%of 14 checked claims hold up–no questions to answer
–of 16 checked claims hold up–of 24 questions answered
Fact or Fluff
Supported7Partly supported6Contradicted by evidence1
14 claims checked against independent sources, chosen by a fixed rule (every material claim (one that supports an argument, a policy or an attack) in the transcripts that count towards a score; in other transcripts, up to 10 claims spread evenly across each; plus any claim an emotional passage relies on). 0 more were found but not checked yet; they do not count.
Quotes leave out filler sounds and repeated words. Words in [square brackets] correct a transcript that misheard or misspelt them. The transcript keeps every word as published.
Supported80% confidence
“His Chancellor resigned as Defence Secretary because the Labour Government would not increase defence spending to 3% by 2030”
Claim checkedJohn Healey, now Andy Burnham's Chancellor, resigned as Defence Secretary because Keir Starmer's Labour Government would not increase defence spending to 3% of GDP by 2030.
John Healey resigned as Defence Secretary on 11 June 2026, saying the Defence Investment Plan settlement fell well short; reports said it took spending to about 2.68% of GDP by 2030, not the 3% he had pressed for. He became Chancellor under Andy Burnham on 20 July 2026.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported60% confidence
“when he was the shadow Home Secretary, when the then Labour leader wanted us to leave NATO, disarm our nuclear deterrent and defund the Army”
Claim checkedWhen Andy Burnham was shadow Home Secretary (2015–16), the then Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn wanted the UK to leave NATO, give up its nuclear deterrent and defund the Army.
Andy Burnham was shadow Home Secretary under Jeremy Corbyn from September 2015 to October 2016, and Corbyn had long opposed renewing Trident and had said he would take the UK out of NATO. No source found shows Corbyn proposing to 'defund the Army', so that part of the statement goes beyond the evidence.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported90% confidence
“The Prime Minister says the target is 2035”
Claim checkedPrime Minister Andy Burnham says the Government's target date for its defence spending commitment is 2035.
In the same session the Prime Minister said the Government would honour NATO commitments of 3.5% by 2035, with a plan at the spending review; he did not commit to a date for 3%.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported65% confidence
“Argentina is threatening the Falklands—now”
Claim checkedArgentina is currently threatening the Falkland Islands.
On 3 September 2026 President Milei announced sanctions on oil companies working off the Falklands, a sovereignty bill and a new naval base nearby; the UK restated its commitment on 4 September. These were political, economic and legal steps, not military action.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported70% confidence
“Russia is threatening us in the North sea—now”
Claim checkedRussia is currently threatening the UK in the North Sea.
At the end of August 2026 the Royal Navy tracked the Russian destroyer Admiral Levchenko escorting sanctioned cargo ships through the North Sea and the Channel, and reported more call-outs to monitor Russian activity than in 2025. The checked core is Russian naval activity near UK waters at the time.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported80% confidence
“The Chancellor used to say that not hitting 3% by 2030 would put our troops at risk”
Claim checkedJohn Healey, now Chancellor, said when he resigned as Defence Secretary in June 2026 that not reaching 3% of GDP on defence by 2030 would put British troops at risk.
In his resignation letter as Defence Secretary (June 2026), John Healey argued for 3% of GDP on defence by 2030 and warned that without such a plan he would have to make decisions that would 'increase the risk to personnel on operations'. He also wrote that the Prime Minister had been 'unable' and the Treasury 'unwilling' to commit the resources.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported85% confidence
“He also said that Keir Starmer was “unable”, and the Treasury “unwilling”, to provide that funding”
Claim checkedWhen he resigned as Defence Secretary, John Healey said Keir Starmer was "unable", and the Treasury "unwilling", to provide funding to reach 3% of GDP on defence by 2030.
Healey's resignation letter of 11 June 2026 told Keir Starmer: "you have been unable, and the Treasury has been unwilling, to commit the resources that the nation needs". The quote matches.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported70% confidence
“On Monday, Chris Rokos, Britain’s third biggest taxpayer, announced that he was leaving the country”
Claim checkedOn Monday 7 September 2026, Chris Rokos, ranked Britain's third-biggest taxpayer, announced that he was leaving the UK.
On Monday 7 September 2026 Bloomberg reported, citing people familiar with the matter, that hedge fund founder Chris Rokos was moving his tax residency to Greece. The Sunday Times Tax List ranked him Britain's third-biggest taxpayer, at an estimated £330 million. The move was reported by others, not announced by Rokos, and his fund declined to comment.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported60% confidence
“That is £330 million of taxes walking out the door because of this Labour Government—every year, £330 million”
Claim checkedChris Rokos, Britain's third-biggest taxpayer, leaving the UK because of the Labour Government means £330 million a year in lost taxes.
£330m matches the 2026 Sunday Times Tax List estimate of Chris Rokos's UK tax for one year, and he announced a move of his tax residence to Greece. The estimate can include business taxes, his firm keeps UK operations, and one year's figure does not show £330m lost every year.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported50% confidence
“The benefits bill is set to rise by £32 billion under him”
Claim checkedThe UK benefits bill is set to rise by £32 billion under Prime Minister Andy Burnham.
The OBR's March 2026 forecast has welfare spending rising from about £353bn in 2026-27 to £390bn in 2029-30, so a rise of this size holds in direction. The basis for exactly £32bn was not found, and it does not match the total-bill forecast.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported55% confidence
“The Prime Minister will not approve the Rosebank oilfield—£1.4 billion of tax revenue”
Claim checkedAs of 9 September 2026, Prime Minister Andy Burnham will not approve the Rosebank oilfield, which would bring in £1.4 billion of tax revenue.
The industry body Offshore Energies UK projects that Rosebank would raise £1.4 billion in tax before the end of this Parliament, rising to £3.8 billion by 2034. Campaigners dispute that figure. On 9 September 2026 the government had not refused Rosebank: a decision was still pending after a consultation that closed in August, and ministers said there was 'no deadline'. Saying the Prime Minister 'will not approve' it goes beyond the record.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Partly supported75% confidence
“Keir Starmer’s £35 billion surrender of the Chagos islands and its crucial military base”
Claim checkedKeir Starmer's deal to hand the Chagos Islands, with the Diego Garcia military base, to Mauritius costs £35 billion.
£35bn is the nominal total of payments to Mauritius over 99 years (£34.7bn, Government Actuary's Department figures); the Government puts the net present value at about £3.4bn. The treaty, signed in May 2025, keeps the base under UK control and was not yet ratified in September 2026.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Supported75% confidence
“the Prime Minister’s Government are cancelling £30 million of vital training for British soldiers”
Claim checkedAndy Burnham's Government is cancelling £30 million of training for British soldiers.
In early September 2026 the Army was reported to have halted large-scale collective training for the rest of the financial year to save about £30m, with deploying and standby units exempt. The Army said training continues and is prioritised.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Contradicted by evidence60% confidence
“Last year, defence funding fell in real terms”
Claim checkedIn the last year (2025/26), UK defence funding under the Labour Government fell in real terms.
A House of Commons Library briefing (22 July 2026) says defence spending rose steadily to £62.0 billion in 2025/26, the highest level in its real-terms series (2025/26 prices). Full Fact found the MoD budget for 2025/26 was about 3.2% higher in cash terms than 2024/25 and slightly higher in real terms. The Conservative claim appears to rest on a reported £2.6 billion in-year MoD saving, not a real-terms fall in total spending.
Our model rated this · methodology v7Counts in Accuracy
Not yet reviewed by a person
Not counted
2
Procedural claims (the speaker's own dates, petition counts, who said what, background), clear slips of the tongue, and words read out from someone else. They stay on the record and do not count in Accuracy.